Management Workshop, News, Regulations

THE Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) is increasing its pressure on the Labor government to address the serious unintended consequences being inflicted on car retailers who are selling their businesses. 

They say that dealers are being unfairly captured in a merger and acquisition fees regime due to a failure by the treasury to understand the business structures of car retailing and that using revenue as a measure of the size of a car business is a mistake.

The AADA has been lobbying hard for many months to convince the treasury that it has got it wrong as far as the rules apply to car dealers. 

The AADA has now sent a letter to federal treasurer Jim Chalmers and the assistant treasurer Andrew Leigh that has been signed by more than 300 dealers urging the government to reconsider the mergers and acquisitions fee structure as it affects car retailers because, they say, the rules are based on a false premise.

Each of the 300+ dealers signing the letter employ up to 300 people. 

The association says that capturing car retailers into the rules on the basis of the revenue of the business does not reflect the true competitive size of the business.  This is because the revenue of a car dealership is inflated by the sale price of each car sold.

It amounts to measuring the revenue of, for example, a real estate business by including the price of each property it sells in the calculation of its revenue.

The level of revenue matters because it is being used to determine fees charged by the ACCC in its role to determine the effects the sale of a business might have on competition.

It matters because the new M&A approvals regime that was put in place last January carries with it eye-watering filing fees of such magnitude that the national dealer body believes it will stand in the way of many dealer acquisitions.

The letter from dealers to the treasurer and assistant treasurer follows a report by BDO Australia prepared for the AADA and presented to the treasury which called the costs of the regime  as “disproportionate”.

BDO Australia said in its report that an initial application for a waiver seeking exemption from ACCC scrutiny of the deal (that it will not lessen competition in the market) costs $8300 in filing fees plus substantial legal preparation costs. 

If the ACCC raises a red flag and the approval goes to the next step (described as Phase 1) the fees rise by an additional $56,800.  If it goes to Phase 2, depending on the value of the deal, it will cost an additional fee of between $475,000 and $1,595,000. The fee for a Public Benefits Phase is $401,000.

The dealers added in their letter that since the commencement of the new merger notification regime, dealers, accountants, lawyers and transaction advisers have reported a significant increase in the cost and complexity of buying and selling dealership businesses.

“For small and medium-sized dealers, these costs are often incurred before it is even clear whether a transaction requires notification. Professional advice is increasingly required to assess notification thresholds, connected entity provisions, cumulative acquisition rules and compliance obligations. 

“In many cases, these costs are being incurred for transactions that ultimately raise no substantive competition concerns.

The letter said that dealers involved in proposed mergers have reported filing fees, legal costs and the costs of advisory services are costing hundreds of thousands of dollars.

AADA CEO James Voortman

“This for an industry which in recent months has averaged close to zero per cent profitability. Furthermore, the sheer number of hours spent by staff having to comply with the extensive information requests from the regulator are stifling productivity.

“Alarmingly, there is now a sense in the industry that the cost and complexity of this new regime will deter small-to-medium sized dealer groups from expanding, ensuring that the only entities able to navigate the cost and red tape will be the largest dealer groups in the country.

“These costs are not being incurred because dealership transactions threaten competition. 

“Rather, they are being incurred because the high-value nature of motor vehicles artificially inflates turnover figures, causing many transactions involving small and medium-sized dealers to be captured by a regime designed to address fundamentally different competition concerns.

“The unintended consequence is that transactions which would otherwise preserve local employment, maintain consumer access to authorised servicing and create businesses capable of investing in Australia’s automotive future become more difficult, more expensive and potentially less attractive to pursue.”

The dealer letter said: “These businesses employ thousands of Australians, support apprenticeships and local economies, and provide consumers with access to vehicle sales, servicing, repairs and warranty support. 

“These are not publicly listed businesses, but typically family-owned dealerships which have served their communities for generations.

“We support strong competition laws and measures designed to prevent mergers that substantially lessen competition. 

“However, we are increasingly concerned that the new merger notification regime is capturing a large number of dealership transactions that pose little or no competition risk because turnover thresholds are being applied to an industry where turnover is a poor measure of market power.

“In particular, we are concerned that dealerships such as these will lose the opportunity for a dignified exit from this industry during a period of immense disruption characterised by the arrival of many new brands, cut-throat competition, massive shifts in market shares and the closure of many franchises.”

The letter added: “Franchised new car dealerships are fundamentally different from most businesses subject to merger control. “Dealers do not control vehicle supply, define sales territories or independently determine many aspects of their commercial operations. Vehicle manufacturers retain significant control through franchise agreements, including approval of ownership transfers, market area allocations, network planning and limits on franchise concentration. 

“These controls remain in place regardless of who owns the dealership,” the letter said.

Referring to the issue of competition, the dealers added that Australia’s new vehicle market is one of the most competitive in the world. 

“There are currently 67 vehicle brands operating in Australia, with forecasts suggesting that number could increase to approximately 75 by 2031. Thousands of franchised dealerships compete both between brands and within manufacturer networks and the overwhelming majority of dealers have less than 2 percent of new car sales market share.

“Despite this highly competitive environment, many transactions involving small and medium-sized dealerships are captured simply because motor vehicles are high-value products.”

The letter pointed out to the treasurer that a dealership can generate tens of millions of dollars in annual turnover while operating on modest margins and possessing very limited market influence. 

Turnover becomes a poor proxy for market power despite being a principal trigger for notification under the new (M&A) regime.” – dealers

“As a result, turnover becomes a poor proxy for market power despite being a principal trigger for notification under the new (M&A) regime.”

The dealers said that the issue has become particularly significant in 2026.

“The automotive industry is undergoing one of the most substantial periods of transformation in its history. Government initiatives including the National Electric Vehicle Strategy, the Electric Car Discount and the New Vehicle Efficiency Standard are accelerating the transition towards lower-emissions transport and fundamentally reshaping the Australian automotive sector.

“For dealers, the direction is clear. Australia’s dealer network will need to support significantly higher levels of electric vehicle sales while investing in the infrastructure, facilities, technology and workforce capability required to service and maintain those vehicles. This transition is only moving in one direction.

“At the same time, a record number of manufacturers are entering the Australian market, many focused on electric and low-emission vehicles. Yet annual new vehicle sales remain broadly static at approximately 1.2 million vehicles. In practical terms, an increasing number of brands are competing for the same pool of customers.“The impact of these changes falls most heavily on small and medium-sized dealers.

“These businesses are being required to invest heavily in EV charging infrastructure, workshop upgrades, specialised diagnostic equipment, technician training, software systems and manufacturer-mandated facility improvements. They are doing so while navigating intensified competition, margin compression, rising compliance costs and broader economic uncertainty.

“In these circumstances, acquisitions and succession transactions involving small and medium-sized dealers are increasingly driven by the need to achieve scale, strengthen balance sheets and secure the capital required to meet the challenges ahead.

“These transactions are not motivated by a desire to accumulate market power. Rather, they are being undertaken to respond to owner retirements, succession planning challenges, increasing capital requirements, evolving consumer demand, new market entrants and the substantial investment required to support Australia’s decarbonisation objectives. 

“Dealers need to scale up in order to remain viable and comply with the changing demands being placed upon them by governments, manufacturers and consumers,” the letter said.

The dealers asked the government to review the application of the merger notification regime to franchised dealership transactions and, in particular, to review whether turnover is an appropriate measure of competition risk in a sector characterised by intense competition, significant manufacturer oversight and comparatively low margins.

Small and medium-sized dealers will play a critical role in delivering Australia’s automotive transition.

If they are expected to invest in the infrastructure, training and technology required to support

Australia’s emissions reduction objectives, they must also be able to achieve the scale necessary to fund those investments.

Without reform, the businesses most affected will be the small and medium-sized dealers that form the backbone of Australia’s franchised automotive retail network and the communities they support.

By Neil Dowling

Manheim
AWN Insurance
Manheim
VACC
PitcherPartners
Indiqator
AdTorque Edge
MotorOne
Impel
AutoGrab
Gumtree
MotorOne
VACC
Indiqator
AdTorque Edge
Gumtree
ConnectedVehicles
Impel
PitcherPartners
AutoGrab
Schmick