Scott Hardie
AS CAR retailers face loan approval rates as low as 30 to 35 per cent from their prime lenders, KPMG Motor Industry Services has published a wide-ranging white paper for dealers which is effectively a roadmap for restoring F&I revenues in car showrooms.
The consulting and accounting group’s white paper addresses the dichotomy of dealers working desperately to improve their loan penetration rates to recover lost commissions while, on the other hand, facing very conservative loan approval rates which are not only hurting actual finance sales but blocking sales to genuine buyers who want new cars.
The paper, written by finance industry stalwart and dealer specialist Scott Hardie, outlines a whole series of steps dealers can take to correct their woes in F&I including a proposal to line up alternative funders to roll in if their primary lender cannot make a deal.
“At the moment, this is a key issue,” Mr Hardie said in the report, “as many of the prime lenders have tightened up their lending volume.”
Mr Hardie, who has been in the industry for 33 years working mostly for GMAC and St George, said 93 per cent of buyers need to borrow money to buy cars.
“So having alternate lenders who are easy to do business with is critical at a time when dealers need to increase penetration to stay profitable,” he said in the report.
Mr Hardie said that if dealers had already taken significant steps to reinvent their F&I practices in the current climate, and their loan approval rate was still well down at 30 to 35 per cent, “it may be time to consider the implementation of a third-party brokerage aggregator such as Brokers Mutual Acceptance Dealer Services”.
This chart shows what KPMG MIS believes the auto finance market will look like if dealers, by joining in with an aggregator or with their own credit licence (ACL) can tap into an additional 38 per cent of the funding available. This would move penetration rates to exceed 70 per cent, which is where they need to be to maintain and grow their income levels.
He said companies such as these could provide dealers with the ability to access other lending institutions that “may be able to approve some of the loans that their current financier is not purchasing”.
“Every lender is very different in their approach to business and in their ability to waive certain aspects of an application that may see an approval forthcoming,” he said.
“Whilst the majority of lenders have similar affordability/serviceability models, some have more relaxed policies on certain level applicants and will approve loans and, in particular, commercial loans such as chattel mortgage.
“This will of course lead to more sales in the dealership and create a more sustainable level of profitability across the entire dealership including additional commissions for the operators that are involved in the process, eventuating in a much more desirable workplace.
“Some of these broker aggregators are offering very good market rates and commission payments, with the majority being paid to the dealership as a return for the incremental volume dealers can provide them.
“In some cases and, where agreed volume targets are reached, volume bonus payments can be forthcoming, hence restoring profitability back into the F&I department that has somewhat diminished with the recent ASIC changes.

“With the possibility of changes to the point-of-sale exemption rules, and in order to provide safety to the dealership for any changes to this regulatory framework, dealerships (with the exception of existing credit licence-holders) are at real risk of not being able to provide any financial facilities at the dealership.
“Hence the inclusion of a third-party broker aggregator could ‘short circuit’ all this due to the business manager operating under the relevant broker aggregator’s credit licences.”
Mr Hardie said there can be as many as 10 to 15 additional lenders that dealers could access “which allows for a much broader approach with more opportunity to obtain loan approvals and assist in selling more vehicles, whilst maintaining profitability for the dealership”.
He said that the implementation of a third-party aggregator could open the opportunity for a ‘one stop shop’ for secondary finance – that is, consumers who can be processed via the F&I department who may not be purchasing the motor vehicle or truck or piece of equipment from that dealership.
“This adds incremental value and income and needs to be a strong consideration for all dealerships of any size in order to make up for the loss in revenues from the reduced commissions,” he said.
Mr Hardie said such a move would also see the aggregator provide full guidance, training and auditing to the compliance requirements of all loans and in particular the consumer-based loans governed by the National Consumer Credit Protection Act 2009.

Ongoing training days would also be available to assist with the annual training requirements, and also daily product training and support would be made available.
“When we look at the composition of the finance market going forward, it’s clear that, for the dealers to increase their penetration to 70 per cent to retain their income, there will be a need to tap into the secondary lending market to bridge the gap,” he said.
“The existing prime lenders (captive and non-captive) are actually reducing their lending to the automotive market, whilst the traditional competitive lender (the home loan top-up) has been all but removed from the market currently, but this may not be the case forever so let’s capitalise on the opportunity now.
“This creates an enormous opportunity for dealers to bridge the gap and increase their overall volume of lending and penetration to 70 per cent. But who is actually going to provide the funding?
“We see the aggregators like Brokers Mutual Acceptance Dealer Services and others that have the additional tools and products, which will give the dealers access to additional volume that they are losing.
“This process is absolutely critical moving forward to maintain profitability at the dealership and improved income for the business manager,” Mr Hardie said.
By John Mellor














Read More: Related articles