Dealerships, News, Regulations , ,

AUTOMOTIVE lobby groups have laid out their plans on what they hope the recently announced review of the Franchise Code of Conduct will achieve with special emphasis on including the farm machinery, motorcycle and truck dealers.

The fact that these dealers were not included in the code has been the subject of numerous and frequent representations from the industry to the federal government and the fact they were not included in the code in the first place has been described as a “terrible oversight”.  

In a memo to members, the industry policy advisor of the Victorian Automotive Dealer Association (VACC), Michael McKenna said the Motor Trades Association of Australia (MTAA) will be making a submission on behalf of its franchise dealer members that will have a particular emphasis on the introduction of extended franchising code of conduct protections for commercial vehicle, motorcycle, farm machinery and industrial machinery dealers.

Mr McKenna said the previous government had in effect created two regulatory regimes for dealing with automotive franchise dealerships. One that is comprehensive, the other which is not. 

“This outcome is disturbing as the infrastructure requirements, capital expenditure, and business model of the truck, farm, motorcycle and farm and industrial machinery dealers left out of the legislation is identical to that of a new car dealer, yet they have less regulatory protection. We hope this changes after this review.”

The review is to be conducted by Dr Michael Schaper a former deputy chair of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and former ACT Small Business Commissioner.

The VACC said the industry welcomed Dr Schaper’s appointment. It said Dr Schaper “is well known to the VACC and MTAA and has extensive experience with the franchising and broader small business sector”.

The CEO of the Australian Automotive Dealer Association, James Voortman, said that “Dr Schaper brings the necessary expertise and experience to this critical review of Franchising Regulations and the Code of Conduct”.

Referring to dealers left out of the current code, Mr Voortman said: “This review provides an opportunity to expand the provisions to encompass truck and other automotive franchised dealers who are currently not afforded the automotive specific protections the Franchising Code provides,” he said.

Mr Voortman told GoAutoNews Premium the areas that the industry will be pursuing in the review are:

Security of tenure / length of agreements:

“We remain concerned over the ability of OEMs to offer short-term dealer agreements. While most credible OEMs offer five-year agreements we do occasionally see agreements which can be for as little as a one-year term. Dealers deserve security of tenure as do their customers who often make purchases with the expectation that they will be bringing a vehicle back for servicing to a specific location over an extended period of time.  

 

Fit for purpose dispute resolution processes:

“Resolving disputes through the court system works against dealers. The process is costly and time consuming. 

“We have seen a number of disputes between OEMs and dealers before the courts which have dragged on for years at great expense to dealers who will never have the same resources as larger multi-nationals. 

“We need to consider something new, such as the approach in Canada where the industry has come together to develop a comprehensive system of arbitration.  

 

James Voortman

James Voortman

Expansion of Unfair Contract Term (UCT) protections:

“All dealers and all franchisees for that matter should be afforded protection from unfair contract terms. We have seen progress with dealers employing less than 100 covered by such protections from November this year, but we believe this should be extended to all.

 

Inclusion of truck dealers in franchising and UCT protections:

“The automotive provisions developed in 2020 and amended in 2021 did not include truck dealers which was a glaring oversight. Truck dealers and other appropriate franchised automotive sectors need to be included as a matter of urgency.”

Mr Voortman said: “This review will be a significant step in ensuring a fair and transparent business environment for new car and truck dealers across the nation and the AADA welcomes the government’s commitment to continually improve this vital regulatory framework.” 

“In recent years there have been several high-profile automotive franchising disputes, a number of which remain before the courts. Now is an opportune time to review franchising regulations to ensure that they remain fit for purpose and the Code is effectively protecting new car dealers and their customers,” Mr Voortman said.

The VACC told members that the code review will evaluate previous reforms and bring a number of reviews under one umbrella, including statutory reviews of the Franchise Disclosure Register and new car dealership protections in the Code. 

Specifically, the Franchising Code of Conduct Review will have regard to the following:

  • The general fitness for purpose nature of the Franchising Code which is due to sunset on 1 April 2025.
  • The role of the Australian Competition and Consumer Commission and the Australian Small Business and Family Enterprise Ombudsman in supporting enforcement and dispute resolution under the franchising regulatory framework.
  • Importantly for retail automotive, the role of the Franchising Code in regulating the automotive sector, including:
  1. Whether Franchising Code protections available to automotive franchisees should be extended beyond new car dealerships (for example to truck, motorcycle and farm machinery dealerships). This is a key priority for VACC franchise members.
  2. The effectiveness of 2020 and 2021 reforms which:
  • provided for multi‑party dispute resolution and clarified that agency models are captured by the Franchising Code
  • created new obligations relating to compensation in the event of early termination, and franchisees’ capacity to make a return on investment
  • provided additional protections to apply at the end of a franchise term including notification requirements and processes for winding down
  • restricted the franchisors’ capacity to require a franchisee to undertake significant capital expenditure
  • clarified the operation of the Franchising Code obligation to act in good faith in relation to new car dealerships.
  • The impact of 2022 reforms which increased certain penalties available under the Franchising Code to: the greater of $10,000,000 or three times the benefit obtained; or 10 per cent of annual turnover.

The Minister for Small Business Julie Collins said that “the Albanese Government is committed to a framework which promotes positive commercial relationships and fair trade and doesn’t unduly restrict competitive conduct”.

By John Mellor

Manheim
AWN Insurance
Manheim
Indiqator
PitcherPartners
AdTorque Edge
MotorOne
VACC
Gumtree
AutoGrab
Impel
VACC
Gumtree
Impel
Indiqator
AdTorque Edge
ConnectedVehicles
AutoGrab
MotorOne
PitcherPartners
Schmick