Dealerships, News, Regulations ,

HIGH hopes by car retailers that a review of the franchising sector would include more recognition of the specific needs of franchised car dealerships within the code of conduct rules have been dashed by a report that virtually ignored protections for the vital auto sector.

Earlier this month Dr Michael Schaeper sent to Canberra his review of the Franchising Code of Conduct which was to assess the fitness for purpose of the code, but with special focus on its present suitability in regulating the automotive sector.

According to HWL Ebsworth Lawyers, overall, the report “did not recommend any meaningful changes to how the code affects the automotive sector other than recommending the definition of ‘motor vehicle dealership’ in the code should be amended to clarify that it includes all sales, service and repair work.

 A review by HWL Ebsworth automotive specialist partner, Evan Stents, he said that despite submissions lodged by the Australian Automotive Dealer Association (AADA) and the Motor Trades Association of Australia (MTAA), “the report did not contain any recommendations to:

  • Have a stand-alone code for dealers
  • Provide better protections for dealers’ investment in goodwill
  • Expand the code to cover other ancillary automotive sectors such as trucks, farm machinery and motor cycles
  • Remove ‘no fault’ termination rights
  • Expand the operation of the ‘unfair contractual terms’ regime to all franchises/dealers
  • Have minimum terms for dealer agreements
  • Provide dealers with the exclusive right to exercise a renewal option.”

HWL Ebsworth said the following findings and recommendations were made by Dr Schaeper that are relevant to the automotive sector:

  • The code is generally fit for purpose
  • Overall, Part 5 of the code (that deals with motor vehicle dealers) appears to have improved the operating environment for new vehicle dealers
  • Recommended that the definition of motor vehicle dealership in the code should be amended to clarify that it includes all sales, service and repair work. 

This came about due to distributors seeking to instigate agency arrangements having stand-alone Service & Parts Agreements which are separate from the Agency Agreements

This issue was considered by the Federal Court in the context of the recent Mercedes-Benz decision. Mercedes-Benz contended that its service and parts agreement with the dealers did not meet the definition of a franchise agreement

  • Reviews of the code should be conducted in five yearly cycles in the future. The next review of the code should consider whether Part 5 (dealing with motor vehicle dealers) should be retained and, if so, whether it should be extended to other sub-sectors such as trucks, farm machinery and motorcycles
  • The existing requirement that new vehicle dealership agreements must provide a reasonable opportunity to make a return on investment should be extended to all franchise agreements
  • The Australian government should investigate the feasibility of introducing a licensing regime to better regulate most aspects of the franchisee-franchisor relationship
  • On balance, no further adjustments or changes are recommended regarding the obligation to act in good faith at this time. The current code obligation is appropriately calibrated to the nature of franchising, as distinct from other business models. Good faith should not operate so as to confer benefits that contradict the express terms of a franchise agreement
  • The absence of a legal right for a franchisee to be compensated for goodwill in franchising contracts is well established. However, if a franchise agreement is terminated early by a franchisor, through no fault of the franchisee, it appears reasonable to provide some compensation
  • The lack of success of the voluntary binding arbitration mechanisms to date may point to the need for the government to consider alternative solutions to achieve speedy and cost-effective resolution of disputes in the sector. However, the current Code cannot be amended to provide for the mandatory arbitration of disputes. As such, it is worth considering the utility of an ex ante regulatory scheme to deliver binding dispute resolution in a cost-effective manner
  • The existing requirement that new vehicle dealership agreements must include provisions for compensation for franchisees in the event of early termination should be extended to all franchise agreements.

The CEO of the AADA, James Voortman told GoAutoNews Premium: “It’s not what we wanted.  We would have preferred the independent review to have adopted a lot more of the recommendations we put forward in our submission.  

James Voortman

James Voortman

“The independent reviewer has come up with one or two recommendations which are suitable for dealers, but by and large, we don’t think it even comes close to going far enough.

“The one thing I would say is this is a review to the government and not of the government. So we will obviously work with the government to try and convince them that what’s been recommended is one part of what is needed, but that there’s a lot more to it, and that we need to go further in terms of automotive franchising regulations.”

Asked if there should be a separate franchising code for the auto industry, Mr Voortman said that was not necessary.

“I think first prize is for the existing regulations to be strengthened. A separate code will take quite a lot of time. It would involve new legislation and everything we want in a separate code can be achieved within the existing regulations,” he said.

“I am not averse to a separate code if it gives us more than we have now. But I think the best possible solution is to amend the automotive provisions of the existing franchising code.

“That will get us the quick protections that our industry needs now.”

Asked if the AADA was disappointed to see that the code did not recommend the inclusion of the truck, farm machinery and motorcycle dealers, Mr Voortman said it was “completely illogical” that they remain excluded from the code.

“In my opinion, the review team was flippant about not including truck dealers in particular. There is no difference between truck dealers and car dealers. You are often talking about the same OEMs. They are very similar. The power imbalance is similar and the investment required is similar.”

“So truck dealers to my mind should have been included and I can’t understand why they were not. It is something we are going to be pushing really hard with this government is why those truck dealers are not included.

“I have always said that the protections that exist specifically for car dealers always pass the common sense test. And you can make the same case for truck dealers. They should have exactly the same protection as car dealers and I struggled to see how the independent reviewer can justify not extending those protections,” Mr Voortman said. 

The Government has stated that it will carefully consider the findings and recommendations from the review before making a response and will no doubt come under intense lobbying from the dealer and trade associations.


Footnote: More than 1,700 franchise entities were invited to participate in the review’s consultation, with 95 formal submissions received, over 40 meetings and roundtables held, and 544 responses across two surveys.

The last review of the Franchising Code was undertaken by Alan Weinn in 2013.

By John Mellor

AWN Insurance
Manheim
Manheim
Indiqator
Impel
Gumtree
AdTorque Edge
VACC
PitcherPartners
MotorOne
AutoGrab
MotorOne
Impel
AutoGrab
VACC
PitcherPartners
AdTorque Edge
Gumtree
ConnectedVehicles
Indiqator
Schmick