DESPITE the rush to embrace the tailpipe zero emission benefits of EVs and the growth of the new electric car market, predictions of a 50-plus percent market share by 2030 have been doubted by expert panellists speaking at the recent AADA Convention and Expo.
In fact, speakers considered that a 20 per cent new-vehicle market share for EVs would be closer to reality.
Previous optimistic predictions centred around the desire of consumers to embrace EVs but the panel talked of huge technology advances being adopted in alternative automotive power plants, including substantially revitalising the internal-combustion engine to produce significantly less emissions.
Speaking on the subject of ‘Retail Automotive – The Next Five Years’ was Cox Automotive Australia and NZ CEO Stephen Lester, Canada Automotive Dealer Association president Tim Reuss; Toyota Australia vice president Jack Hobbs; MTA WA CEO Stephen Moir; and with moderator, AADA CEO James Voortman.
Mr Reuss brought a perspective from Canada, a market and consumer profile not dissimilar to Australia but with a government that adopted a federal mandate to pursue low vehicle emissions.
Although Mr Reuss would not be drawn into predicting an EV market share for Australia, he showed how mandates could be used by governments to enforce the sales of EVs above alternative vehicles.
“Just over 10 per cent of vehicles sold in Canada were EVs this year; the year before that it was about 8.5 per cent; the year before that was 5 per cent,” he said.
“Growth, if you want to be an optimist, has doubled in two years, but EVs are still only 10 per cent.
“That 10 per cent across Canada is made up of 20 per cent in British Columbia and Quebec, and about 2 per cent in Saskatchewan and Manitoba. And even within the 20 per cent of British Columbia, there’s only about 3 per cent in downtown Vancouver and in rural areas of Columbia, it’s about 2 per cent.
“This contrasts with what the government is dreaming about, which is 60 per cent by 2030 and 100 per cent by 2035.
“That’s a federal mandate. And we also have a mandate in British Columbia and Quebec of 85 per cent and 90 per cent, respectively, by 2030.
“So from 10 per cent now to 60 per cent in the next five years, with the government hoping to achieve that with Soviet-style mandates.”
Mr Reuss said that discussions within the automotive industry in Canada and the federal and state governments are showing that political ambitions and market realities are at odds and that consumer demand “isn’t out there.”“The same thing has happened in the US. Brands have started to retract some of the (EV) programs based on market realities.
“So what do we expect in the next five years? Something’s going to have to give. What’s going to have to give is, actually, this (current) government, which is probably on its way out.
“We’re already working with the incoming governments to hopefully have more realistic goals in place, where yes, EVs will be part of the solution, but won’t be the only solution.”
The CEO of Cox Automotive Australia, Stephen Lester, said: “Thank goodness we’re not back in Canada, because listening to those mandates is a very frightening thing.”
Mr Lester is a former Canadian automotive executive with BMW and Infiniti before taking on the role of vice president and managing director of Nissan Australia in 2017.
He said he believed that Australia was in the “early adopter stage” in EVs and is “probably a couple of years behind the markets like Canada or the US.”
“Certainly, in five years’ time, we’re going to see some increase in EVs, but we’re also going to see some continued diversification of the overall power trains that are offered.
“There will not be an ‘on-off’ switch into an EV market. That probably will never happen. So I think the market will diversify with other models coming to the market.
“I think hybrid, for which we’re hungry today, along with a massive proliferation of technology, driven by the NVES and the strong effect that’s going to have.
“Plug-in hybrids still continue to gain market share, but it’s probably in the teens, I would say, by the time we get into 2030. We’re beyond thinking about 100 per cent EVs and in those terms, 2035 as a timescale is absolutely nowhere.”
The CEO of the Motor Trade Association of WA, Stephen Moir, said EVs will command 20 per cent “at best” of the new-vehicle market within 15 years.
“And the reason for that is – I’ll use Norway as the gold standard – that they spent 2.3 trillion euros over the past 10 years in providing incentives to EVs,” he said.
“In Australia we have a government that’s not giving anything really – they’re not removing LCT and they’re not getting any real meaningful incentives. And they want us to get EV sales up to ridiculous levels.
“EVs will remain part of the solution to reducing emissions. There are much greater advancements recently in combustion-engine technology, hydrogen fuels, and so on.
“So I think the next five years will be really exciting as to where it lands. But for EVs, I see probably about 20 per cent market share at best.”
Toyota Australia vice president Jack Hobbs said: “I see a multifaceted approach to technology so that we can all contribute to decarbonisation without leaving anyone behind.”
“The technology we’re seeing today will continue to evolve. By the end of this decade, we expect that there will be some gains in solid-state batteries which could see a range of 1000km and maybe a charge time of 10 minutes.”
Mr Hobbs said plug-in hybrids will also play a large role, terming them the “Goldilocks” transitional solution with EV use in the city and petrol for country trips.
He also said Toyota’s ongoing commitment to hybrids and alternatives including fuel-cell and biofuels would be ongoing and provide solutions where demand existed.
On battery electric vehicles, he said: “My prediction, by 2030, maybe 25 per cent” of the Australian market.
By Neil Dowling
















Read More: Related articles