News, Technology

Read Part 2 – ICE vs EV utes – click here

FEW things are as contentious and as liable to misrepresentation as the comparison between electric vehicles (EVs), especially in commercial applications where performance and purchase price compete for buyer attention.

An effective method of comparison for vehicles put to commercial use, particularly for fleets, is calculating total cost of ownership (TCO).

Queensland-based vehicle engineering business AusEV uses TCO calculated by an Australian firm to show clients the practicalities and potential cost savings of EVs in different scenarios. 

AusEV told GoAutoNews Premium that different situations will show ICEs will have a lower TCO but that in the majority of cases, an EV is less expensive and has less demands on operators in terms of time to organise scheduled servicing and in driver comfort and safety.

Maintenance costs of an EV are “significantly lower” than an ICE equivalent, said AusEV executive Tom Shipsides.

The reasons, he said, included the less moving parts in an EV, longer service intervals and little need to replace components such as brake parts because of regenerative braking and ‘one-pedal’ driving modes. 

AusEV’s calculations are based on factors such as maintenance costs factored at $200 an hour.

This favours EVs with their low service needs and as many industries – including mining – have reduced service intervals, costs can quickly increase for ICEs.

There are pros and cons with both ICEs and EVs. The primary difference is the high price of an EV, especially one for work purposes.

AusEV compared a Ford F150 Lightning Pro (EV) costing $161,900 (ex GST and ORC) with a Ford F-150 XLT (ICE) at $97,220 (ex GST and ORC) for GoAutoNews Premium.

The F150 XLT has a 3.5-litre bi-turbo V6 petrol engine rated at 298kW/678Nm and mated to a 10-speed automatic transmission. The Lightning has two electric motors driving all four wheels. The combined output is 337kW/1050Nm.

The comparison was based on each vehicle being owned for four years and travelling a total of 200,000km. (A more expensive F150 Lariat was also included in the comparison but not included here as the operating costs are the same as the XLT)

Mr Shipside said the calculations are flexible enough so parameters can be changed to suit individual circumstances, but using a set of data common to the industry, the TCO of a Ford EV is substantially less than that of the F150 ICE.Taking into account the purchase price, operating costs, maintenance, CO2 emissions and disposal, the EV’s TCO was $133,317.41 against the XLT ICE at $167,626.25 – a difference of $34,308.84).

“There’s an $8,000 fleet discount on the EV in NSW which makes it more attractive, bringing the purchase price down to $153,900 (ex GST and ORC)”

Even removing the CO2 component, the EV is in front by $31,192.82.

Mr Shipsides said the potential for a carbon tax and a road-user charge (for EVs) should also be considered by owners when making comparisons between an EV and an ICE. 

Neither road-user charges nor a penalty for carbon are as yet legislated in Australia. However, companies impacted by the ‘safeguard mechanism’ monitored by the Clean Energy Regulator are required to buy credits on The Australian Carbon Market (to meet their base line targets).

The regulator has set in legislation a price cap of $75 per tonne for scope 1 emissions and it is this charge that can affect TCO.

The calculations show that over the four years, a carbon penalty would be $753.22 for the EV and $3869.23 for the ICE. In total, the EV has CO2 emissions of 21.5 tonnes and the ICE has a hefty 110.5 tonnes.

The data also shows the cost of electricity for the EV averages 20c/kWh and the EV gets 25.3 kW/h over 100km ($5.06 per 100km). This compares with the ICE at 12.5 litres/100km (at a cost of $2 a litre for $25 for 100km).

In summary, the F150 Lightning EV costs 66.7 cents per kilometre and the F150 XLT ICE costs 83.8c/km.

Mr Shipsides said the comparison shows the EV saves significantly on maintenance and fuel costs over the period of ownership.

“It is important to look at the total cost rather than just upfront costs,” he said.

There are other factors that can affect the choice, including the availability of charging stations. The Lightning EV also has the ability to become a mobile battery pack, giving it greater functionality over ICE equivalents and one of the reasons why EVs are becoming prized in remote areas and a feature that can increase resale value.

The bottom line is that the EV is the TCO winner of the two F150s but that individual circumstances and conditions can alter the result and calculations based on these individual cases may be paramount to the final decision.

Read Part 2 – ICE vs EV utes – click here

By Neil Dowling

Manheim
AWN Insurance
Manheim
AutoGrab
MotorOne
Gumtree
VACC
Indiqator
PitcherPartners
AdTorque Edge
Impel
PitcherPartners
Gumtree
Indiqator
AdTorque Edge
ConnectedVehicles
Impel
MotorOne
VACC
AutoGrab
Schmick