Technology , ,

Neville_Jackson_portrait

Neville Jackson

ONE of the world’s premium engine development companies, Ricardo plc, has applauded Nissan’s groundbreaking variable-compression petrol engine going into production for its Infiniti luxury brand.

But the company says that while variable compression engines had long been a Holy Grail for car-makers, the Nissan engine – dubbed VC-T and announced this week – appeared to be a complex solution to the long-standing problem.

In an exclusive interview with GoAutoNews Premium, Ricardo chief technical officer Neville Jackson said there were other, less complex systems that were designed to provide the best balance between performance and fuel economy.

The 101-year-old UK-based Ricardo has been responsible for a string of innovations including refining the engines for the Voyager round-the-world aircraft, developing transmissions for Ferrari and Jaguar, creating the flywheel kinetic energy storage concept, and designing and producing the McLaren 3.8-litre V8 engine.

Prof Jackson said he applauded Nissan for announcing production of its VC-T engine.Nissan_Tech

“The Japanese are very good at launching technology and taking it to the market and I think that’s an excellent way to advance technology,” he said.

“They don’t always make it but they are very good at launching the concepts.

“There are many ways of doing what Nissan’s VC-T will do and the challenge is finding the balance between cost and effectiveness.”

Nissan’s new engine is able to cater to both economy and performance by fluidly switching compression ratios, and Prof Jackson said the breakthrough comes after decades of attempts by other companies and individuals.

INFINITI_VC_T_engine_01

This view was echoed in early 2013, when the then Audi technical director and longstanding Volkswagen chief engineer Ulrich Hackenberg told GoAutoNews that the variable compression engine was the one breakthrough he would most like to achieve in engine design as he believed the technology to be one of the key solutions to the future of internal combustion engines.

Prof Jackson told GoAutoNews Premium: “Variable compression ratio (VCR) engines have been around for quite a few decades and everyone’s had a dabble at it yet hasn’t reached production.”

When asked why, he said: “The challenge with VCR engines is that while it is a very good approach to address a number of issues, it is difficult to implement the best of combustion while minimising the drawbacks such as complexity, cost and increases in parasitic losses.”

Parasitic loss is basically any loss of the engine’s power or fuel economy from more complex systems increasing friction, for example.

Nissan_tech_2

“The challenge is always to have sufficient benefits to offset the disadvantages,” Prof Jackson said. “So far most companies have decided that there really are not enough benefits to justify the costs.”

He said that Ricardo has “a completely technology agnostic approach” to this issue.

“The challenge is that you are trying to address an issue that can be resolved by using other approaches,” Prof Jackson said.

“It’s not just the issue of looking at advantages – one must also look at other ways to obtain similar benefits, by taking a simpler approach such as variable valve timing or a combination of approaches that are easier to implement.

vcr_technische

“Our overall philosophy has been to compare those different ways of going about things and our approach at the moment is slightly different to using VCR but actually achieving pretty much a similar effect.”

Prof Jackson said Ricardo was working on improvements to the engine’s variable-compression expansion rate, creating an engine that allows for greater combustion area expansion that it does for compression.

“We do that by changing the valve timing, much more so than you would do in a conventional engine,” he said. “It is done mechanically, just by rotating the valve system or variable-cam system, particularly on the inlet system.

Prof Jackson said this method was a “great advantage” and can achieve “a variable compression ratio as Nissan has stated from 8:1 to 14:1” just by changing the valve timing.

“What it also allows us to do is to cool the charge further through, for example, supercharging and an intercooler. This has great advantages.”

Prof Jackson said he sees a future in internal combustion engine as having the same issues as today.Infiniti-VC-T

“Systems such as VCR and variable-valve timing and others go a long way to maintaining internal combustion engines,” he said. “But I don’t think there is one solution.

“The challenge with VCR is its complexity and its cost. For example, there are additional bearings on the crank which add friction in an era where we are trying so hard to reduce engine friction.”

Meanwhile Prof Jackson questioned Nissan’s claim that its new VC-T engine would mark the end of the diesel engine.

“It is a bit far fetched to say that a petrol engine will replace the diesel engine,” he said.

“I don’t believe we’ve seen the end of the diesel engine. It is possible for a petrol engine to get close to a diesel in performance and fuel economy, but it gets expensive.

“Of course, on the other hand, diesels have more expensive emission devices to reduce pollutants, but there are answers to that problem.

“The diesel has specific characteristics such as low-speed torque that is desirable in a car and that is difficult to replicate with a small-capacity petrol engine.”


 

Electric Dreams

EV dominance a long way off, says engine expert

RICARDO plc chief technical officer Professor Neville Jackson has told GoAutoNews Premium that he is less bullish than many car-makers in predicting a future where electric vehicles replace internal combustion engines.

“I don’t hold the view that we are headed very soon to an electric vehicle future,” Prof Jackson said.

“Electric vehicles are only part of the solution. When the transport situation suits it, electric vehicles make sense, such as for short journeys in the city.

“Plug-in hybrids also have advantages for longer journeys. But we have to remember that, at the moment, to get a 300km range from an electric vehicle requires a battery weighing up to 700kg.

“For the future, say to 2030, I see more of the same.

“There will be greater efficiencies in engines and much greater electrification. That is, from micro-hybrids to 48-Volt systems, to hybrids and plug-in hybrid and electric vehicles.

“This will go on for some time. Consumers will still be offered internal combustion engines.

“But if you want performance, there will be more emphasis on electric. I can see all performance cars having to change to using electrification.

“But I think the internal combustion engine has a long way to go.”

By Neil Dowling

Manheim
Manheim
AWN Insurance
Indiqator
AutoGrab
PitcherPartners
MotorOne
Impel
VACC
AdTorque Edge
Gumtree
AutoGrab
ConnectedVehicles
VACC
Gumtree
Impel
Indiqator
PitcherPartners
MotorOne
AdTorque Edge
Schmick