Although McKinsey looks initially at the opportunities of car-makers, the report – A Virtuous Cycle for Growth: Finding Profit after the Initial Sale – includes enhancing the revenue streams open to dealerships, including finance and insurance, servicing and reselling the original vehicle.
McKinsey said that the focus still tends to be on a single transaction at the dealership.
“What’s needed instead is a mindset that seeks to monetise a vehicle identification number (VIN) across the entire life of the vehicle, creating a virtuous cycle powered by advanced analytics whenever possible,” the report said.
“This becomes a self-reinforcing strategy; as each stage of the product life cycle is optimised, it compounds the benefits of each of the other stages.
“Advanced analytics is powering this shift from selling cars to maximising the profitability of each vehicle for as long as it’s on the road. When executed correctly, we have seen a strategy based on the virtuous cycle add up to 12 to 15 per cent to margin growth while also growing revenue.
“In addition, companies experience faster sales of their most profitable products, enhanced brand equity, and a stronger bond with their customers.”
The report said there were six elements in the process of driving profitable growth. But it warns that “all elements are interconnected and a failure to manage any single element correctly can trigger risk, and destroy value, in the others.”
McKinsey’s six elements for profitable growth
1. Packaging the options:
Many car-makers selling in Australia now do this by creating specific packs that bundle the most popular options. McKinsey said manufacturers and dealers can use data on customer preferences to create these packs and, by monitoring similar pack offerings by rivals, can identify and exploit gaps in the market.
2. Set the right price points:
Determine the price customers are willing to pay for each type of transaction, including lease, financing, and cash sales. The next decision is to determine the optimal split between the recommended price and incentives.
Pricing can be customised by region, trim level, or VIN. Historical data can be used to get a detailed understanding of the elasticity curve, looking for opportunities to decrease incentive spend (thereby increasing margins) without losing significant volume.
3. Dealer margins optimised to align with manufacturers’ goals:
Setting the dealer-margin percentage should be an opportunity to position products in a way that drives a car-maker’s overall strategy. Instead, in many cases, dealer margin becomes almost an afterthought, just a flat percentage regardless of trim level.
Analytics can be used to determine the overall percentage of dealer margin for each trim level. By adjusting margins based on the actual profitability of products, car-makers provide greater incentives for dealers to push for the highest-profit sales.

4. Financing:
Competitive financing options will increase profits and consumer loyalty and can create additional revenue streams from well-thought-out insurance and warranty programs.
McKinsey said that a prime example of this is the use of analytics for advanced customer segmentation – similar to that offered by credit-card companies. Advanced segmentation can create personalised financing/leasing offers that can help close the sale and increase revenues.
5. Aftersales and services:
Generate additional revenue and loyalty by targeting offerings throughout the product life cycle.
This can be done by offering a service format for price-conscious consumers and those with older models. Some car-makers, for example, offer lower-cost service formats in stand-alone locations, targeting owners who would be unlikely to pay the higher prices for service at the dealership.
These low-cost service offerings can achieve profitability by using lower-cost labor and a warranty on parts that may be remanufactured. Handled correctly, these lower costs offset the lower prices.
6. Remarketing:
The quest to maximise profitability throughout the entire life of the vehicle must include the period after the first trade-in or lease return. Besides driving additional profitability, focusing on this stage of the product life cycle gives car-makers greater control over their brand and retains customer loyalty at the dealership.
Once a vehicle is purchased by a second owner, for example, and developing a deep understanding of customer demand, the dealer can analyse the relative value of both dealership and auction channels and determine pricing strategies for each.
Analysis of the market may also mean the dealer could shift specific vehicles – for example, 4WDs – to regions where there is a higher demand and a higher price, such as regional centres. Remarketing also includes the re-leasing of vehicles that have come out of their initial lease and are put back into the market with a much cheaper lease price.
This gives buyers a quality car at a much cheaper lease and maintains the customer with the dealership.
The McKinsey report said that the virtuous cycle is predicated on a strategy focused on the entire product life cycle.
“It requires collaboration across organisational silos, new performance metrics and incentives, and possibly new kinds of talent,” it said.
“At times it may also require a surrender of the primacy of traditional metrics, such as new-car revenue, in favour of supporting overall profitability for car-makers and dealers.

“This new approach may require some fundamental cultural changes. For one thing, car-makers will need to look beyond their immediate organisation and form closer relationships with their ecosystem partners to ensure access to data:
- Dealers are traditionally reluctant to share information in dealer management systems with car-makers; car-makers must provide financial incentives tied specifically to data sharing to ensure access.
- Captive-finance partners can continue to serve as a source of cash flow that is somewhat disconnected from the cycle of new-car volume. Still, car-makers should view them not as a profit centre but as a support function for the core business.
- Car-makers can improve their access to data by working with third-party data providers, such as JD Power for example. They can provide incentives for dealers to participate in reporting, which improves the quality of the JD Power data, and work to create integrated data systems that improve the usability of that third-party data, compared to interfaces that show only specific categories of information.
By Neil Dowling
















Read More: Related articles