Regulations , ,

VW AG’s settlement with the US Government over the diesel defeat device affair has cost the company at least $A30 billion in penalties and compensation so far in the US alone, but the penalty the regulators were entitled to inflict could have been greater than five times the $A6 billion finally levied.

The sheer enormity of the laws that the VW AG breached in the US was such that, had the US Government chosen to throw the book at the German auto maker, the penalty could have bankrupted the company.

The reason the penalty might well have been greater is that VW AG broke US laws at so many levels in so many jurisdictions. But it is clear that the Americans took a pragmatic approach; there was no point in bankrupting the company because then no-one would get paid anything and it would cause financial hardship on some many employees who were not to blame for what happened.

Indeed it is known that the US Department of Justice has done extensive research on VW AG’s ability to pay and assesses the penalties, not so much on the maximum they can levy under the law, but on a level of pain that would erode any financial advantage the company received from any breach as well as a level of penalty that would prevent the company from ever trying such a thing again.

In the event the penalty of $A6 billion was on the high side of predictions made by specialist litigators who suggested it would be about $1 billion.

It is instructive to run through the list of where breaches occurred that would have attracted massive penalties in their own right.

First there were the breaches of US EPA and California CARB emissions rules.

Allowing cars to be sold that spewed up to 40 times the NOx levels than were legal was worth billions. Here is how that would have been totted up.

The offences took place from 2009 to 2015 and we are now hearing involved nearly 600,000 US vehicles (early figures suggested 490,000 units involved.)

According to court documents the complaint was not only against VW AG and Volkswagen Group of America it was also against Audi AG and Porsche AG although these were all grouped under VW AG

The EPA penalties alone should have been around $A35 billion dollars had the full force of the law been brought to bear on VW.

Under the penalties, VW AG was liable to civil penalties of up to $US32,500 per “2.0L subject vehicle and $US32,500 per 3.0L subject vehicle” for each violation occurring before January 13, 2009, and civil penalties of up to $US37,500 per 2.0L subject vehicle and $US37,500 per 3.0L subject vehicle” for each violation occurring on or after January 13, 2009.

Since most of the cars were sold from 2009 the $US37,500 ($A46,900) penalty would have applied across 600,000 vehicles making a grand total of $US28 billion ($A35 billion).

There court papers also referred to a civil penalties of up to $US37,500 per day of violation on or after January 13, 2009, This makes a further penalty of $US91.2 million or $A115 million.

Theoretically California could have weighed in separately; as well as a number of other states but the agreed settlement lets VW off the hook from any more civil actions.

Another major area is the breach of consumer protection and advertising laws which were breached by blatant lies made to the market about the “clean diesel” engines. VW represented itself as having uniquely created a high-performance, super economical engine that was super clean in advertising. It did so to dealers and customers, in media briefings, in national, state and local advertising and in millions of sales promotion brochures.

It would be impossible to to total up the potential penalties because it happened on so many occasions in so many consumer jurisdictions at so many levels over the period from 2009 to the end of 2015. The price paid for that could be said to be the multi billion dollar compensation package, but it still appears that the company has got away with the paying a penalty for this malfeasance at the consumer level.

The third major area is that of cheating customs rules.

By importing cars and engines fitted with the defeat device VW AG must have falsified compliance documents for US Customs which meant that the non-complying engines were imported illegally.

In VW’s case, VW AG would have to have made made false declarations for every non-complying engine sent to the US and VW Group of America would have been liable for penalties in declarations in documents associated with the importing of the engines.

Those actions prompted US officials to remove the company from a trusted-cargo program overseen by US Customs and Border Protection, and as result VW vehicles and engines imported to the US face a greater risk of lengthy delays at border crossings.

So, while they have not exactly dodged a bullet, VW management got off a lot more lightly than could have been the case – except for those bound for the slammer.

By John Mellor

AWN Insurance
Manheim
Manheim
Gumtree
VACC
PitcherPartners
AutoGrab
Indiqator
MotorOne
Impel
AdTorque Edge
Impel
PitcherPartners
Gumtree
MotorOne
Indiqator
VACC
AutoGrab
AdTorque Edge
ConnectedVehicles
Schmick